A few days or weeks ago, I posted on Facebook: "Pondering the dissolution of bedtime. You can "make" them go to bed, but you can't make them go to sleep. Maybe I just need to go all Mrs. Piggle-Wiggle on them." I loved Mrs. Piggle-Wiggle books growing up. I think I still have one. She was the wise older lady who gave great advice to parents whose children were misbehaving. Like the kid who wouldn't take a bath. She told the parents not to make the child bathe. To cover him with a fine dirt and sprinkle seeds. And after a few days, plants started growing on him. And then he would take a bath without complaint. Or the kid who wouldn't pick up her toys. So her parents didn't make her. And then she got trapped in her room and couldn't get out when Mrs. Piggle-Wiggle was taking the children on a parade around the neighborhood. So she cleaned them up and learned her lesson. Mrs. Piggle-Wiggle was wise like that.
I think the sleep example I'm thinking of may actually be The Cosby Show, though. When Rudy wants a later bedtime, so her parents say she can stay up as late as she wants. And eventually she's so exhausted that it's affecting her at school and she can't enjoy the rest of her life. But regardless, we went through a period of weeks when it seemed none of our children would go to sleep. And somehow, we got to the other side. Some of these things we did, I think. But others were probably a result of those phases that kids go through. Who knows.
Zola has always gone to sleep well. I (with help from my mom, while I was on a trip) had to get her to sleep through the night, but she's never cried at bedtime. She got her pacifier, laid down, grabbed her blanket, and went to sleep -- on her belly with her but in the air. That was it. She hardly moved all night. But then a month ago I decided she needed to get rid of the pacifier. We went cold turkey. I did the first two nights when Wes was working and wouldn't have to hear her cry. I rocked her, sang to her, and put her down. I went down every 10-15 minutes to calm her down. After 60-90 minutes, she would give in and go to sleep. And for at least four weeks I tried this. Every 4-5 days, I would get a night when she only cried for 20 minutes. Or a few when she would cry for 3 and then go to sleep. Some nights I would stay down there and just talk to her when she cried. Some nights I would pat her back, which kept her from crying, and left my hand on her until she fell completely asleep and I could tiptoe out. I don't know exactly how that's better than a pacifier, but I was giving it a go. Then my family came into town for Oliver's birthday. One night she fell asleep faster than ever before. The next night she was screaming at the top of her lungs for 20 minutes before I got her back up. My mom held her, and she finally fell dead asleep and went down. Some days after that, decided I just couldn't do it. Letting her cry for at least an hour every night just seemed dumb. For a whole month, she never had a pacifier. I never caved and gave it to her. I never let her have it at nap. In fact, she'll go down in the very same crib at naptime and not cry. But bedtime was different, and no amount of "sleep training" was working. Hearing her cry every night made me physically tense. I was angry at her for not going to sleep. I was tense with the other kids. I was mad at myself for not being able to fix the problem. So I've gone back to the pacifier -- for now. I'll try again when she's 18 months, and I might try some kind of intermediary like I did with Emmeline -- a gumdrop pacifier in her case, to give her something to soothe but that wouldn't stay in as easily. For now, I think it's better for all of us.
Emmeline, on the other hand, has never easily fallen asleep. When she was a baby, she nursed and rocked to sleep and used a pacifier. Then I stopped nursing. Then we got rid of the pacifier. For a few days and weeks, she would cry for about five minutes and then fall asleep. But she never just went to bed. And she still doesn't. She talks and sings and squirms around in her bed. When we moved to the new house, we had to put a lock on her door to keep her in her room because she wouldn't stay in there. She'd come out with 15 requests and questions after bedtime, and before we knew it, it was an hour later than when we laid her bed. Sometimes she'd go into Oliver's room. Sometimes he'd tell us, but usually they'd just play until I heard them down there. I tried sitting next to her room for as long as it took for her to go to sleep, just to keep her in bed. But once I stopped, she began again, and so we did the lock. Now she doesn't try to come out, and we don't have to put the lock on. So long as I put her on the toilet right before bed, she usually doesn't have an excuse. She still sings and talks, but we even seem to have minimized that. We get the kids into bedtime soon after dinner now, and then we either play a game, read books, or watch 20 minutes of a show or movie. But every night, I read Emmeline the same two books up in her bed -- Llama Llama Nighty Night and If I Could Keep You Little. She knows every word but still wants to read them over and over and over again. There's no decisions about what to read. We read those. If we read other books, it's earlier and on the couch in the living room. Every night, though, is these two books in her bed. Then I plug in a nightlight that projects the solar system onto her ceiling, turn out the overhead light, and tell her she can look at the books until she falls asleep. And she rarely comes out. I've never seen anything like it with her before this.
And then there's Oliver. Who doesn't nap and hasn't in years. Who went through a few weeks of sleeping in really late. He gets ready for bed with his sister and reads or watches with her, but most nights he gets another 20 minutes. We let him work on his Lego sets that have pieces too small for his sisters. Or he works on his road track in his room until he's sleepy. Or, like Emme, he looks at books in bed. Most nights we even say goodnight and tell him to turn off his light when he's tired. We go back 20-30 minutes later, and his light is out and he's asleep. He was never one to get up much, and he doesn't now unless he needs to use the bathroom.
We've also taught Emme to come into our room -- not Oliver's -- when she wakes up, which means he's sleeping to a more reasonable hour than her. Actually, 6:30 is pretty normal for a 2-year-old, just sometimes earlier than I'd like to get up!
I know as time passes their sleep cycles will change. It's fall, the weather is beautiful, and the kids are getting plenty of outdoor time to wear themselves out. Winter may be more challenging if they're too still. But for now, it does seem to have improved. And there does seem to be a commonality with the big kids that letting them "do something" quietly after tuck-in time lets them decide when they're ready to lie down and fall asleep. That Mrs. Piggle-Wiggle. She's a smart lady.
I think the sleep example I'm thinking of may actually be The Cosby Show, though. When Rudy wants a later bedtime, so her parents say she can stay up as late as she wants. And eventually she's so exhausted that it's affecting her at school and she can't enjoy the rest of her life. But regardless, we went through a period of weeks when it seemed none of our children would go to sleep. And somehow, we got to the other side. Some of these things we did, I think. But others were probably a result of those phases that kids go through. Who knows.
Zola has always gone to sleep well. I (with help from my mom, while I was on a trip) had to get her to sleep through the night, but she's never cried at bedtime. She got her pacifier, laid down, grabbed her blanket, and went to sleep -- on her belly with her but in the air. That was it. She hardly moved all night. But then a month ago I decided she needed to get rid of the pacifier. We went cold turkey. I did the first two nights when Wes was working and wouldn't have to hear her cry. I rocked her, sang to her, and put her down. I went down every 10-15 minutes to calm her down. After 60-90 minutes, she would give in and go to sleep. And for at least four weeks I tried this. Every 4-5 days, I would get a night when she only cried for 20 minutes. Or a few when she would cry for 3 and then go to sleep. Some nights I would stay down there and just talk to her when she cried. Some nights I would pat her back, which kept her from crying, and left my hand on her until she fell completely asleep and I could tiptoe out. I don't know exactly how that's better than a pacifier, but I was giving it a go. Then my family came into town for Oliver's birthday. One night she fell asleep faster than ever before. The next night she was screaming at the top of her lungs for 20 minutes before I got her back up. My mom held her, and she finally fell dead asleep and went down. Some days after that, decided I just couldn't do it. Letting her cry for at least an hour every night just seemed dumb. For a whole month, she never had a pacifier. I never caved and gave it to her. I never let her have it at nap. In fact, she'll go down in the very same crib at naptime and not cry. But bedtime was different, and no amount of "sleep training" was working. Hearing her cry every night made me physically tense. I was angry at her for not going to sleep. I was tense with the other kids. I was mad at myself for not being able to fix the problem. So I've gone back to the pacifier -- for now. I'll try again when she's 18 months, and I might try some kind of intermediary like I did with Emmeline -- a gumdrop pacifier in her case, to give her something to soothe but that wouldn't stay in as easily. For now, I think it's better for all of us.
Emmeline, on the other hand, has never easily fallen asleep. When she was a baby, she nursed and rocked to sleep and used a pacifier. Then I stopped nursing. Then we got rid of the pacifier. For a few days and weeks, she would cry for about five minutes and then fall asleep. But she never just went to bed. And she still doesn't. She talks and sings and squirms around in her bed. When we moved to the new house, we had to put a lock on her door to keep her in her room because she wouldn't stay in there. She'd come out with 15 requests and questions after bedtime, and before we knew it, it was an hour later than when we laid her bed. Sometimes she'd go into Oliver's room. Sometimes he'd tell us, but usually they'd just play until I heard them down there. I tried sitting next to her room for as long as it took for her to go to sleep, just to keep her in bed. But once I stopped, she began again, and so we did the lock. Now she doesn't try to come out, and we don't have to put the lock on. So long as I put her on the toilet right before bed, she usually doesn't have an excuse. She still sings and talks, but we even seem to have minimized that. We get the kids into bedtime soon after dinner now, and then we either play a game, read books, or watch 20 minutes of a show or movie. But every night, I read Emmeline the same two books up in her bed -- Llama Llama Nighty Night and If I Could Keep You Little. She knows every word but still wants to read them over and over and over again. There's no decisions about what to read. We read those. If we read other books, it's earlier and on the couch in the living room. Every night, though, is these two books in her bed. Then I plug in a nightlight that projects the solar system onto her ceiling, turn out the overhead light, and tell her she can look at the books until she falls asleep. And she rarely comes out. I've never seen anything like it with her before this.
And then there's Oliver. Who doesn't nap and hasn't in years. Who went through a few weeks of sleeping in really late. He gets ready for bed with his sister and reads or watches with her, but most nights he gets another 20 minutes. We let him work on his Lego sets that have pieces too small for his sisters. Or he works on his road track in his room until he's sleepy. Or, like Emme, he looks at books in bed. Most nights we even say goodnight and tell him to turn off his light when he's tired. We go back 20-30 minutes later, and his light is out and he's asleep. He was never one to get up much, and he doesn't now unless he needs to use the bathroom.
We've also taught Emme to come into our room -- not Oliver's -- when she wakes up, which means he's sleeping to a more reasonable hour than her. Actually, 6:30 is pretty normal for a 2-year-old, just sometimes earlier than I'd like to get up!
I know as time passes their sleep cycles will change. It's fall, the weather is beautiful, and the kids are getting plenty of outdoor time to wear themselves out. Winter may be more challenging if they're too still. But for now, it does seem to have improved. And there does seem to be a commonality with the big kids that letting them "do something" quietly after tuck-in time lets them decide when they're ready to lie down and fall asleep. That Mrs. Piggle-Wiggle. She's a smart lady.




